What Happened
On July 25, 2025, the New York Yankees acquired third baseman Ryan McMahon from the Colorado Rockies in exchange for minor league pitchers Griffin Herring and Josh Grosz. This trade comes as the Yankees sought to address significant struggles at the third base position, where they had received subpar offensive production throughout the season. McMahon, a 30-year-old left-handed hitter and an All-Star in the previous season, was activated to the Yankees’ roster and made his debut in the lineup against the Philadelphia Phillies shortly after the trade.
The Yankees took on McMahon’s contract, which includes approximately $4.5 million for the remainder of the 2025 season and $32 million over the next two years. McMahon’s performance this season has been mixed; while he has shown defensive prowess, ranking among the top third basemen in the league, his offensive statistics have been below average, with a batting average of .217 and a 92 OPS+.
Key Details
- Trade Participants: New York Yankees received Ryan McMahon; Colorado Rockies received Griffin Herring and Josh Grosz.
- Contract Details: McMahon is owed approximately $4.5 million for the remainder of 2025 and $32 million for the 2026 and 2027 seasons.
- Performance Statistics:
- McMahon’s batting average: .217
- Home runs: 16
- OPS: .717
- Defensive metrics: 4 Outs Above Average, ranking him in the 91st percentile among third basemen.
- Minor League Prospects:
- Griffin Herring (22 years old): 1.71 ERA in 89⅓ innings across Low- and High-A.
- Josh Grosz (22 years old): 4.14 ERA in 87 innings over 16 games at High-A Hudson Valley.
This trade marks a significant move for both franchises, with the Yankees looking to bolster their infield defense and offensive output, while the Rockies aim to build for the future by acquiring young pitching talent.
Multiple Perspectives
Opinions on the trade vary among analysts and insiders. Supporters of the Yankees’ acquisition argue that McMahon fills a critical need at third base, providing both defensive stability and potential offensive improvement over the Yankees’ previous options, particularly Oswald Peraza, who has struggled significantly at the plate. Yankees manager Aaron Boone noted McMahon’s experience and defensive capabilities, expressing excitement about the acquisition.
Conversely, some analysts point out McMahon’s inconsistent offensive performance, particularly his struggles away from Coors Field, where he has historically performed better due to the altitude. Critics argue that while McMahon’s defense is commendable, his offensive output may not significantly elevate the Yankees’ overall performance, especially given his below-average wRC+ throughout his career.
From the Rockies’ perspective, general manager Bill Schmidt emphasized the need to focus on building for a competitive future, suggesting that trading McMahon, despite his talent, was a necessary step. The return of two young pitchers, while not elite prospects, is seen as a positive move towards rebuilding the team’s pitching depth.
Context & Background
The trade occurs against the backdrop of a challenging season for both teams. The Yankees have struggled with injuries and inconsistent play, particularly at third base, leading to a pressing need for improvement in that area. McMahon’s acquisition is viewed as a strategic move to enhance the team’s chances as they aim for a playoff berth.
The Rockies, on the other hand, have been in a prolonged rebuilding phase, currently holding one of the worst records in Major League Baseball. The decision to trade McMahon, a player who has been with the organization since being drafted in 2013, reflects a shift in strategy as the team looks to develop younger talent and potentially reshape its roster for future competitiveness.
This trade also highlights the broader dynamics of the MLB trade market, where teams are often forced to make difficult decisions regarding player retention versus rebuilding efforts. The Yankees’ willingness to take on McMahon’s contract indicates their commitment to competing in the near term, while the Rockies’ move suggests a long-term vision.
What We Don’t Know Yet
Several uncertainties remain following the trade. It is unclear how effectively McMahon will adapt to the pressures of playing in New York, especially after spending his entire career in Colorado. His performance in the coming months will be closely monitored to assess whether he can meet the expectations set by the Yankees.
Additionally, the long-term impact of this trade on both franchises is yet to be determined. For the Yankees, the effectiveness of McMahon in improving their infield play and contributing offensively will be crucial. For the Rockies, the development of Herring and Grosz into viable major league pitchers will be a significant factor in evaluating the success of the trade.
Finally, as the trade deadline approaches, it remains to be seen how both teams will continue to adjust their rosters. The Yankees may pursue further pitching help, while the Rockies could look to make additional moves to enhance their rebuilding efforts.
