What Happened
On July 25, 2025, the New York Yankees announced the acquisition of third baseman Ryan McMahon from the Colorado Rockies in exchange for minor league pitchers Griffin Herring and Josh Grosz. The Yankees are taking on the remainder of McMahon’s contract, which includes approximately $4.5 million for the remainder of the 2025 season and $32 million over the next two years. McMahon, a 30-year-old All-Star in 2024, was activated to the Yankees’ roster shortly after the trade and made his debut in the lineup against the Philadelphia Phillies.
The trade comes as the Yankees have struggled at the third base position, receiving subpar offensive production from players like Oswald Peraza, who has one of the lowest batting averages in the league this season. McMahon is expected to provide both defensive stability and an offensive upgrade, despite his inconsistent performance at the plate this season.
Key Details
- Trade Participants: New York Yankees received Ryan McMahon; Colorado Rockies received minor league pitchers Griffin Herring and Josh Grosz.
- Contract Details: McMahon’s contract includes $4.5 million for the remainder of 2025 and $32 million for the 2026 and 2027 seasons.
- Performance Metrics: In 2025, McMahon has a batting average of .217, 16 home runs, and a .717 OPS, with a National League-leading 127 strikeouts in 100 games. His defensive metrics are strong, ranking in the 91st percentile with four Outs Above Average.
- Yankees’ Needs: The Yankees have struggled at third base, with a combined OPS of .645 from that position, ranking among the lowest in Major League Baseball.
- Prospects Traded: Griffin Herring, a 22-year-old left-handed pitcher, has a 1.71 ERA in 89.1 innings across 16 starts in the minors. Josh Grosz, also 22, has a 4.14 ERA in 87 innings over 16 games.
Multiple Perspectives
Opinions on the trade vary among analysts and commentators. Some view McMahon as a valuable addition due to his defensive capabilities and potential for offensive improvement, particularly in a new environment like Yankee Stadium, which could benefit left-handed hitters. Yankees manager Aaron Boone expressed optimism about McMahon’s ability to thrive in New York, stating, “He is a presence and can really defend over there at third.”
Conversely, some analysts caution that McMahon’s offensive performance has been below average throughout his career, particularly when playing away from Coors Field, where he has historically performed better. Critics argue that while McMahon’s defense is commendable, his offensive inconsistency raises questions about his ability to contribute significantly to a team with playoff aspirations.
The Rockies’ perspective highlights a shift towards a rebuilding phase, with general manager Bill Schmidt emphasizing the need to build for a competitive future. The trade signals a recognition of the team’s struggles and a willingness to part with a player who has been a significant part of their roster.
Context & Background
The trade occurs against the backdrop of a challenging season for both the Yankees and the Rockies. The Yankees have been grappling with injuries and inconsistent performances, particularly at third base, where they have cycled through multiple players. The Rockies, on the other hand, are in the midst of a difficult season, currently holding one of the worst records in Major League Baseball. This trade represents a strategic move for both teams: the Yankees seek to bolster their roster for a playoff push, while the Rockies aim to acquire young talent for future development.
McMahon’s history with the Rockies includes being drafted in the second round in 2013 and becoming a regular player by 2019. His departure marks a significant moment for the Rockies, who have been hesitant to make trades in recent years, particularly involving homegrown talent.
What We Don’t Know Yet
Several uncertainties remain following the trade. It is unclear how McMahon will adapt to the pressures of playing in New York, especially after spending his entire career with the Rockies. Analysts will be watching closely to see if he can improve his offensive output and whether the Yankees can effectively integrate him into their lineup.
Additionally, the long-term impact of the trade on both teams is still to be determined. The performance of Herring and Grosz in the Rockies’ system will be closely monitored, as will McMahon’s contributions to the Yankees over the next two seasons. The effectiveness of this trade will ultimately hinge on whether McMahon can meet the expectations set by his new team and whether the Rockies can develop the young pitchers they acquired.
